Glass vs Plastic Cloches
Glass vs Plastic Garden Cloches – Which Is Best?
Choosing between glass and plastic garden cloches is an important consideration when planning how to protect your vegetables and extend the growing season.
Both materials can provide useful protection for young plants, but there are significant differences in their durability, appearance, maintenance and long-term value.
Plastic cloches are generally lightweight and inexpensive, making them convenient for occasional use. Traditional glass cloches, on the other hand, offer excellent light transmission, do not deteriorate through UV exposure in the same way as many plastics and can provide many years of service when properly maintained.
In this guide, we compare glass and plastic garden cloches to help you decide which is best for your garden.
What Is a Garden Cloche?
A garden cloche is a protective cover placed over plants to create a more sheltered growing environment.
Cloches are particularly useful for vegetable growing and can help to:
-
Protect young plants from cold winds and heavy rain.
-
Reduce exposure to light frosts.
-
Warm the soil and encourage earlier planting.
-
Provide a sheltered environment for seedlings.
-
Extend the growing season in spring and autumn.
The choice of glazing material affects how a cloche performs and how long it is likely to remain in good condition.
Glass Garden Cloches
Glass cloches have been used by gardeners for generations. Traditional designs include the French bell-shaped cloche, Victorian iron-framed designs and the familiar British barn-style cloche.
Glass remains a popular choice for gardeners who want a durable, reusable product.
Advantages of Glass Cloches
Excellent light transmission
Clear horticultural glass allows high levels of natural light to reach plants. Good light transmission is important for healthy growth, particularly when growing seedlings and early vegetables.
Long service life
Glass does not become brittle or yellow through ultraviolet exposure in the way that some plastics can. With reasonable care, a glass cloche can remain in use for many years.
Individual panes can be replaced
One advantage of a traditional barn-style cloche is its simple construction. If a pane breaks, it can usually be replaced without having to discard the entire frame.
Good resistance to wind
Glass is heavier than plastic, which can help a properly assembled cloche remain stable in exposed conditions. The frame should still be positioned securely, particularly in strong winds.
Easy to clean
Glass can be cleaned to restore its clarity and allow maximum light through to the plants.
Traditional appearance
The classic glass barn cloche has a distinctive appearance that looks at home in traditional kitchen gardens and allotments.
Considerations When Choosing Glass
-
Glass is heavier than plastic.
-
It can break if knocked or handled carelessly.
-
Installation and assembly require some care.
-
Glass panes need to be sourced and cut to the correct dimensions.
Plastic Garden Cloches
Plastic cloches are widely available and come in various forms, including rigid covers, flexible tunnels and lightweight protective sheets.
They are convenient for gardeners who want a low-cost or temporary growing cover.
Advantages of Plastic Cloches
Lightweight and easy to move
Plastic cloches are generally easier to handle and reposition than glass alternatives.
Lower initial purchase cost
Many plastic products are inexpensive, making them attractive for gardeners who only need temporary protection.
Less risk of breakage
Plastic is less likely to shatter if dropped or knocked, although rigid plastic can crack.
Limitations of Plastic Cloches
Deterioration through sunlight
Some plastics deteriorate when exposed to ultraviolet light over extended periods. They can become cloudy, brittle or discoloured, reducing their effectiveness.
Reduced clarity over time
Plastic surfaces can become scratched and weathered, affecting the amount of light reaching plants.
Shorter useful life
Depending on the type and quality of plastic, replacement may be necessary after a number of seasons.
Wind exposure
Lightweight plastic covers can be vulnerable to strong winds and may require additional pegging or securing.
Practical access
Some tunnel-style plastic covers need to be lifted or removed for watering, weeding and harvesting. The inconvenience depends on the particular design.
Glass vs Plastic Cloches – A Direct Comparison
| Feature | Glass cloches | Plastic cloches |
|---|---|---|
| Light transmission | Excellent when clean | Varies with material and age |
| Durability | Long-lasting with care | Can deteriorate in sunlight |
| Weight | Heavier | Lightweight |
| Breakage | Can break | Less likely to shatter |
| Cleaning | Easy to clean | Can scratch and become cloudy |
| Wind resistance | Generally better due to weight | Often needs securing |
| Replacement | Individual glass panes can be replaced | Often requires replacing the cover |
| Appearance | Traditional and attractive | We can have too much plastic! |
| Initial cost | Usually higher | Usually lower |
Which Is Best for UK Gardening?
For gardeners who use cloches regularly and want a long-term solution, traditional glass cloches have several important advantages.
British weather can be unpredictable, with strong winds, heavy rain and fluctuating temperatures throughout the growing season. A well-constructed glass cloche provides a sturdy, reusable shelter for crops.
Glass is particularly attractive if you want to establish a permanent growing area or use cloches year after year.
Plastic cloches can still be useful for temporary protection, particularly where lightweight construction and low initial cost are priorities.
Neither material removes the need to monitor conditions inside the cloche. On sunny days, temperatures can rise quickly, so adequate ventilation is important whatever material you choose.
Long-Term Value – Is Glass Worth the Extra Cost?
Plastic cloches often have a lower purchase price, but their useful life can be limited by weathering, scratching and UV deterioration.
A traditional glass cloche generally costs more initially, but it can remain in service for many years if properly cared for.
The ability to replace individual panes is another important advantage. With a traditional barn-style design, there is no need to replace the complete cloche simply because one piece of glass has broken.
For gardeners who grow vegetables regularly, the long-term value of a reusable glass cloche can make it a worthwhile investment.
When Should You Choose Glass or Plastic?
Choose a glass cloche if you:
-
Want a durable, long-term growing solution.
-
Use cloches regularly throughout the year.
-
Value good light transmission.
-
Prefer a traditional appearance.
-
Want the option of replacing individual glass panes.
-
Are looking for a reusable alternative to short-life plastic covers.
Choose a plastic cloche if you:
-
Need a lightweight cover that is easy to move.
-
Have a limited initial budget.
-
Only need occasional or temporary protection.
-
Prefer a product that is less vulnerable to shattering.
Explore Our Traditional Glass Garden Cloches
At Cloches.co.uk, we specialise in traditional British barn-style glass cloches based on the established Chase design.
Our range includes:
-
High Barn: A taller design providing additional growing space.
-
Low Barn: A lower-profile design for salads and smaller crops.
-
Apex Seedling: A compact design for protecting seedlings and seedbeds.
Our products are supplied as metal frame kits, with glass excluded. This allows you to source the glass locally to the correct dimensions and makes future replacement of individual panes straightforward.
We also supply selected replacement handles and glazing clips to help restore older traditional barn cloches.
Browse our range of traditional glass garden cloches and discover the advantages of this established approach to vegetable growing.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are glass cloches better than plastic?
For regular use and long-term durability, glass cloches have several advantages. They offer excellent light transmission, resist UV deterioration and can provide many years of service. Plastic remains a useful lightweight and lower-cost alternative.
Do glass cloches protect plants from frost?
Glass cloches provide good protection from light, clear sky frosts by creating a more sheltered environment. However, they do not guarantee frost protection in severe or prolonged cold weather. Additional protection may be needed for particularly tender plants.
How long do glass garden cloches last?
With proper care, a glass cloche can last for many years. Individual panes can be replaced if damaged, allowing the metal frame to remain in use.
Do glass cloches need ventilation?
Yes. Temperatures inside a cloche can rise quickly in sunny weather, even when outside temperatures are relatively low. Ventilation helps prevent overheating and allows air to circulate around plants.
Is glass more environmentally friendly than plastic?
Glass is reusable and can have a long service life. Its environmental impact depends on how it is manufactured, transported, maintained and eventually recycled. However, a well-maintained glass cloche can avoid the repeated replacement of short-life plastic covers.
The text of the first chapter, The Principles of Cloche Gardening is provided below
We are a sporting country and we like an element of chance to enter into all our sports and pastimes. Perhaps this is why we are a nation of gardeners, for in the British climate surely there could be no hobby more hazardous, more full of uncertainties than gardening?
We are also fond of records and this may be the reason why we have such a warm affection for our climate and will defend it so stoutly when foreigners complain about it, for almost every month some weather record or other is broken!
In some parts of England or Scotland you will almost certainly have experienced the warmest day, the coldest day, the windiest day, the wettest day or the driest day for fifty years! In spite of all this, Britain is still a most pleasant country to live in, a country in which plants on the whole grow remarkably well, a country where the average gardener grows a greater variety of flowers and vegetables in his garden than anywhere else in the world.
At the same time we do have to put up with a tremendous number of handicaps. We probably dislike late spring frosts more than any other of the difficulties with which we have to contend. Although it is very rarely that they fail to occur, we seem to be taken by surprise every year. In the south of England there is a risk of frosts until mid-May and in the north until early June.
Our gardening programme very largely depends on these dates.
But apart from late spring frost, we are also handicapped by lack of sunshine during the long winter months, by fog and atmospheric impurities, particularly near the industrial towns of the Midlands and the North, by heavy and persistent rain and most of all by cold wind, sometimes of gale force, which is liable to occur during any month in the year.
Gardeners are always seeking protection against these handicaps of the weather. Walled gardens are an attempt to protect from wind and to conserve the warmth of the sun by reflection of heat from the walls. Unfortunately, they are often also frost pockets and although they do ordinarily give a good deal of protection from wind, they sometimes cause alarming whirlwind effects with very serious consequences.
Hedges also make most valuable wind-breaks and in Cornwall and the Scilly Isles they are used extensively to split up gardens into quite small areas to protect the plants from south-westerly gales. Unfortunately hedges take up a great deal of room, for their roots reach out many yards on either side and take moisture and nourishment from the soil.
Glass is by far the most efficient material for protecting plants from wind and from cold. It allows the rays of the sun to pass freely to warm the soil and the plants underneath. At the same time, largely owing to its thickness, it is a good insulator and prevents the warmth from escaping into the open air. The scientific explanation of the reason why glass is effective in cloches and glass-houses is that it offers no obstruction to short-wave radiation which, penetrating the glass and heating the surface below, is changed into long-wave radiation to which glass is opaque. Therefore it cannot 'bounce' out again and stays to warm air, soil and plants underneath the cloches.
It is true that ordinary horticultural glass does not allow the passage of ultraviolet rays but these rays, though essential for animal growth, are not required for plant growth. There is, therefore, horticulturally no advantage in using a special type of glass which allows the passage of these rays.
Greenhouses and frames have been used for several hundred years for the protection of plants, though it is less than a hundred years since the dismantling of the Crystal Palace after the Great Exhibition of 1851 gave the stimulus to the building of commercial glasshouses.
The greenhouse is a great joy and a great help to the home gardener. If he can heat it artificially, he can grow plants to decorate his house and can raise flower and vegetable plants for putting out later on into his garden. A greenhouse has its limitations, however, for vegetable growing and for cut-flower work.
It would be too expensive to grow one crop wholly in the greenhouse and many crops are better not transplanted at all, apart from the fact that transplanting involves additional labour.
Greenhouses also have the disadvantage that they are not open to the wind and the weather and, in consequence, soil which is used inside them becomes exhausted and constantly needs renovating.
Cold frames are much cheaper than greenhouses and they are valuable for raising seedlings. They are usually built with a glass top and opaque sides made either of brick or of wood. This means that their value is greatly reduced during the winter months when the sun never rises very high above the horizon. The vertical framework throws long shadows and it is only the centre of the frame which receives the direct rays of the sun. Further, as the light only comes from above, the plants tend to grow upwards to reach towards the light and this makes them spindly and weak.
Frames need constant ventilation and watering and, unless they are portable, the soil soon becomes exhausted as it does in a greenhouse.
The introduction of cloches is comparatively new, for it is just over forty years since they were first used in private gardens. They are not intended for forcing crops, but for protecting them against cold, wind and rain. Compared with greenhouses and frames they have the advantage that they are very much cheaper.
They are easily moved from place to place so that the soil which they cover for part of the year is open to the elements for the remaining months and can therefore recover and will not become exhausted. Since cloches are made entirely of glass with only a thin metal framework which casts practically no shade at all, light reaches the plants growing underneath them from every direction and there is therefore no tendency for them to become 'drawn'. Cloches are never completely closed for there is always a small gap at the top where the roof panes meet which allows a small amount of ventilation.
Lastly, there is no question of watering under the cloches they are so narrow that all the necessary moisture reaches the plants from outside the glass. This has the added advantage that soil under cloches retains its natural tilth and never gets caked. This is most important for two reasons: first, since air can penetrate freely to the roots of the plants, the necessity for hoeing underneath cloches in order to keep the soil loose disappears altogether; secondly, the fact that the soil is not caked prevents frost from penetrating deeply into the soil even in the coldest weather. This produces a higher soil temperature, enabling root growth to continue throughout the winter months.
Horticulturally, therefore, cloches have many advantages over any other form of glass protection.
Quite apart from this they have the tremendous practical advantage of mobility. Instead of having to bring the crops to the glass to be protected as in the case of greenhouses and frames, with cloches the glass is taken to the crop so that it is easy to transfer the protection from one crop to another. The same set of cloches is used to cover three, four, or even more crops in the same season. It is rarely that the glass is out of use if the cloches are used with intelligence and a cropping rotation is worked out at the beginning of each year.
So far as the layout of the garden is concerned, cloches involve no drastic alteration. Sowings are still made in straight rows, the spacing of these rows being adjusted so that they can be conveniently covered by the cloches. The site chosen for the cloches should be in full sunlight and the shade of houses or trees should be avoided.
Cloches cannot manufacture heat. They simply trap the sunbeams and it is therefore particularly important that they should be sited where the sun can reach them for as many hours of the day as possible. In winter, when sunlight is most needed, the sun never rises much more than twenty degrees above the horizon and even quite low walls and hedges throw long shadows.
It is important to remember that cloches give complete protection from wind. It is not necessary therefore to site them in a sheltered spot. Cloches themselves are resistant to wind and there is no danger of their being damaged provided they are put down evenly on the ground and the ends of the rows are kept closed to avoid draught. In addition to giving complete protection from wind to the crops which are actually growing under the glass, they also give some protection to the rows of plants growing parallel to the cloches and behind them. It is therefore a good plan to site the cloches so that they are at right-angles to the prevailing wind. They will in this way act as hedges and windbreaks for the other crops growing in the garden.
On the western side of the country, heavy and continuous rain does almost as much to check plant growth as wind. First, seed is often washed out of the ground before it has a chance to germinate. Secondly, if the soil temperature is not high enough for germination, the seed rots in the ground if it gets too wet. Thirdly, over-wet conditions cause damping off which rots the stems of the plants. Lastly, heavy rain cakes the surface of the soil and in very cold weather the ground gets frozen solid to a depth of several inches. Many plant diseases flourish most in moist conditions and where the leaves remain wet for long periods. Those who live near the sea know well how much harm salt sea spray can do to plants by caking on the leaf surface and preventing proper transpiration through the leaves.
Cloches are a complete protection from all these handicaps. They direct the rain to the ground outside the cloches so that it never wets the soil immediately surrounding the stems of the plants. There is no other method of cultivation in this country where water does not fall over the whole surface of the ground where the crops are growing. For in greenhouse and frame work the plants must be watered by hand and there is no means of keeping the water away from the roots of the plants.
Rain which falls on rows of cloches trickles down the glass and into the soil just outside. The largest cloches are only two feet wide so that the water is never applied more than half that distance (i.e. twelve inches) away from a crop growing in the centre of the cloche. When moisture enters the soil it moves principally downwards, but also sideways, the degree of lateral movement depending on the nature of the soil and particularly on its humus content. Plant roots similarly grow not only downwards but also sideways, so that crops grown under cloches can obtain all the moisture they require from water falling outside the cloches. The same principle applies if artificial watering is necessary. Water is poured outside the cloches so that the surface of the soil underneath is never wetted.
In very light soils where vertical movement of the water is very rapid, it is a good plan to draw a shallow drill with a hoe just outside and parallel to the cloche row on either side of the glass. This acts as an irrigation channel and encourages lateral movement of the moisture in the soil. If the soil outside the cloches becomes caked from heavy rain, it should be kept hoed, for on a hard surface rain may stand about in pools and evaporate or, if there is a slope on the ground, it will run away. Generally speaking, if cloches are used on sloping ground it is better to let the rows run along the contours. If they run up and down the slope there is a danger that the crop at the top of the slope may receive too little water.
In intensively industrial areas cloches save crops from damage by fog. Those who live in these areas will know that a greasy, black, chemically injurious deposit is left on plant leaves by the fogs that occur so often in winter and early spring. Very often that deposit kills. It always gravely embarrasses the plant on which it rests. The leaves of plants protected by cloches are not covered by this deposit, hence they do not receive even the slightest check by fog.
Cloches are a complete protection from birds and also from dogs, cats and rabbits, but it is essential to keep the ends of the cloches closed or it will be found that some of these creatures like to lie up under the cloches to bask in the sunshine, sheltered from the wind.
The most spectacular feat which cloches accomplish is the protection which they give against frost, particularly late spring frosts. These late frosts invariably occur after a warm, sunny day during which the heat of the sun has warmed the soil under the cloches. At night, when the outside temperature falls, the air under the cloches is kept warm by the heat of the surface soil.
Outside the cloches this warm air rises and is replaced by the cold frosty air, but under the cloches it is prevented by the glass from escaping. As a result, crops under the cloches will be perfectly safe, for there may be as great a difference in temperature as fifteen degrees between the air outside and inside the glass. The glass itself will, however, fall to freezing point, and the air within half an inch or so of the glass will also be very cold. It is most important therefore that leaves and flowers of crops under cloches during the period when night frosts are expected should not actually touch the glass. Always use a large enough cloche for the particular crop you are growing.
During the coldest months of the year the difference in temperature inside and outside the cloches will be very much less than in the late spring; it may be as little as five degrees. The reason is that there is little or no sunshine during the daytime so that the soil under the cloches never gets properly warmed up. Nevertheless, cloches do protect crops growing underneath them from the heaviest frost. The foliage is kept dry, as no rain or mist can fall on it. Plants can stand up to a great deal more frost if they are dry than if they are wet. Secondly, the tilth of the soil under the cloches is retained; this tilth forms an insulating layer through which frost cannot penetrate to any considerable depth. Outside the cloches the soil becomes caked hard and the ground freezes many inches down; every gardener knows that after heavy frost it is impossible to dig the soil without using a pick or crowbar. Under cloches, however, the soil can easily be moved with a trowel even after the most prolonged and severe frost.
It has often been suggested that since glass has the obvious disadvantages of breaking if it receives a blow and of being heavy to move about, other transparent materials could be used as substitutes. Many such materials have been tried. It was hoped at one time that some form of plastic would meet the case. So far, however, no material has been discovered which is anything like as efficient as glass. Some materials have a metal foundation and these have two particular defects: first, the metal rusts after a few seasons and the whole fabric perishes; secondly, the metal mesh casts so much shadow that the plants underneath are light-starved. Materials which have no mesh are necessarily extremely thin if they are made of any reasonably cheap kind o plastic. Unfortunately they cannot maintain a rigid shape, but fall into folds and hollows which cause reflection of light, so that again many of the rays do not penetrate to the crops beneath. Further, thin material does not act as an insulator of heat and in the cold weather nothing like so much protection is giver against frost. Lastly, all these plastic materials scratch and wear and after a season or two a very considerable proportion of the light rays fail to penetrate and are reflected outside.
Some day perhaps a toughened glass will be produced at a cheap price and this will be welcomed by all gardeners. For the time being we must be content with cloches made of horticultural glass which is slightly opaque, but offers no resistance to the passage of any of the rays which are required for plant life. It has the enormous advantage that it is very much cheaper than any other known material which could be used for plant protection.
Mobility of the cloche is one of its essential characteristics. Each cloche is absolutely rigid and one can be carried in each hand and moved quickly from crop to crop. For many of the most important crops like lettuces, carrots and beans, it is unnecessary to get to the plants underneath the glass while they are protected by cloches because they just grow on their own, but with some crops, particularly those which are under the glass during the summer months, work has to be done under the cloches. To give easy access to such crops, barn and tomato cloches are fitted with a device which allows one sheet of glass to be removed to permit the gardener to do any necessary work of stopping, pollination, etc., without moving the cloche. With the simple tent cloches this facility is unnecessary as each cloche is so light that it is less trouble to move it complete than to remove one pane of glass.
Cloches are not intended to be airtight. There is always a narrow gap of an eighth of an inch along the ridge of the cloche and in the case of barn cloches, another gap of the same width at the eaves. These gaps provide a small amount of ventilation and ensure that there is always a slight movement of air under the cloches.
During the greater part of the year this ventilation is sufficient and the ends of the rows should be kept firmly closed with sheets of glass or wood and the cloches should butt fairly closely one to another so that there are only small spaces between adjacent cloches. No attempt should be made to get an airtight fit or to allow the cloches to overlap one another as this may cause breakage and will make it more difficult to move them. The gap between adjacent cloches should be between a sixteenth of an inch and an eighth of an inch. During the hot spells it may be desirable to give extra ventilation to the crops underneath the glass. For this reason, all cloches are provided with a ventilating handle which allows rather more than an inch gap to be given at the top of the cloche. When the cloche is in the ventilated position it is still rigid and can be moved about from place to place. It is not intended that cloches should be opened in the morning and closed at night; this is quite unnecessary and much too laborious. If a hot spell comes the cloches should be opened and remain open until it becomes cold again. Even in the ventilated position it is most unlikely that late spring frosts will damage the crops underneath, but if such a frost is obviously threatened it is wiser to close the cloches. It is of course unnecessary to ventilate all the cloches; every other cloche (or one in five) can be opened to give a smaller degree of ventilation.
If the sun is very hot indeed during late May or the summer months of June, July and August, even more ventilation may sometimes be advisable, particularly if a crop has just been planted and has not yet become thoroughly established. In this case, the wisest thing to do is to remove every other cloche in the row. To save moving them about, they can be stood on end in the position which will be described later for protecting crops from wind. Another method of getting extra ventilation is to space out the cloches so that they stand two or three inches apart. The necessity for using these drastic methods of ventilation will however rarely arise; perhaps once in two years. Ordinarily the ventilation which can be given by opening up the top will be sufficient.